Winning Negotiated Work

How to Measure Your Transition From Low Bid to Negotiated Work

A contractor decides it wants to move away from competing primarily on low bid. Leadership develops a growth strategy, identifies better clients, improves the company’s positioning, and invests in relationships that could lead to more negotiated opportunities.

Six months later, the CEO asks a familiar question: “Is it working?”

Marketing reports increased engagement with target clients. Business development has developed promising relationships. Estimating is becoming more selective about the projects it pursues. But revenue hasn’t changed significantly, and the financial statements don’t show much improvement.

Is the strategy failing, or is the company making progress that hasn’t reached the bottom line yet?

That’s an important distinction because construction growth strategies often take longer to produce financial results than executives expect. A prospective client may need a year or more before an appropriate project becomes available. After the award, construction might not start for several months. Revenue is recognized as work progresses, and payments follow contractual billing and collection cycles.

The financial results of today’s marketing and business development decisions may not become apparent until well into the future. That doesn’t mean contractors should operate on faith. It means they need to measure the right things at the right time.

More Revenue Doesn’t Necessarily Mean Better Business

I’ve worked with contractors that achieved 15–25% year-over-year revenue growth while improving annual net profit margins by three to seven percentage points.

Those improvements didn’t come from marketing alone. They resulted from coordinated changes in business development, client selection, positioning, and operational decisions.

The distinction between revenue growth and margin improvement matters. Consider a contractor generating $100 million in annual revenue with a 3% net profit margin. That’s $3 million in net profit.

If the company increases revenue to $120 million but its net margin falls to 2%, it now earns only $2.4 million. Revenue increased 20%, but net profit declined.

Now consider that same company generating $100 million with a 6% net profit margin. It earns $6 million, twice the net profit at a 3% margin without increasing revenue.

These are illustrative calculations, but they explain why I care more about the bottom line than the top line. Growing revenue while sacrificing profitability can leave a contractor with more employees, greater financial exposure, more complicated projects, and less money to show for the effort.

A successful transition should create a more profitable, sustainable construction company, not simply a larger one.

Measure the Work You’re Winning, Not Just How Much

If the goal is to move toward negotiated and preferred-contractor opportunities, start by understanding how the company wins its current projects. Many contractors know how much revenue comes from different market sectors, but they don’t consistently track how projects were awarded.

I recommend measuring both project delivery methods and contractor selection methods. Delivery methods include design-bid-build, design-build, and construction management at risk (CMAR), among others. Selection methods describe how the contractor was chosen, including competitive low bid, qualifications-based or best-value competition, and direct negotiation.

These are different measurements. A design-build project may be awarded through a highly competitive selection process. A design-bid-build project may involve negotiated work with a trusted contractor. Simply classifying all design-build or CMAR work as negotiated would distort the results.

Track the number of projects and awarded contract value in each category, along with their financial performance. The objective isn’t necessarily to eliminate competitive bidding. Some contractors are exceptionally good at public low-bid work and can deliver healthy margins.

The goal is to build a more diverse portfolio of desirable projects while reducing dependence on opportunities where lowest price is the primary deciding factor.

Industry research supports the relevance of alternative delivery methods. FMI’s 2025 Design-Build Utilization Study, conducted for DBIA, projected continued growth in design-build’s share of the construction spending categories evaluated. But the growth of a delivery method doesn’t guarantee better profitability for any individual contractor. Your company’s actual results matter more than the industry’s overall direction.

Source: FMI, 2025 Design-Build Utilization Study.

Bid Less, Win More, and Measure the Difference

One of the clearest indicators of progress is whether your company is becoming more selective and successful in its pursuits. In Part 3, we discussed the importance of ideal client profiles and scored Go/No-Go decisions. Those tools should become part of your measurement system.

Track the number of opportunities evaluated, their ideal client profile scores, target-account tiers, and final Go/No-Go decisions. Then compare those scores with actual pursuit outcomes.

Are projects with stronger client relationships and better qualifications producing higher win rates? Are low-scoring pursuits consuming resources without generating meaningful results?

Measure proposal volume, proposal hit rate, average project size, and the percentage of awarded value captured. Be consistent with terminology. Proposal hit rate typically measures the number of wins divided by the number of submitted proposals, while dollar-value capture rate considers the value of awarded work relative to the value pursued.

SMPS Foundation research on measuring marketing and business development performance emphasizes the importance of these distinctions.

Source: SMPS, Measuring for Success.

A contractor submitting fewer proposals but winning a larger percentage of better-fit projects may be making significant progress. That improvement can reduce pursuit costs, lessen estimating workloads, and allow more time to develop compelling approaches to desirable opportunities.

But don’t celebrate a higher hit rate without evaluating profitability. Winning more projects because you’re consistently the cheapest contractor isn’t necessarily an improvement.

Look for Progress Before It Appears in Revenue

Construction sales cycles can make executives impatient. The company may be executing the right strategy and developing stronger relationships, but the opportunities haven’t progressed far enough to affect awards or revenue.

That’s why leading indicators matter. Some are measurable, including new relationships within priority accounts, opportunities to participate in early planning, meetings with targeted decision-makers, and invitations to pursue desirable projects.

Others are qualitative. I’ve seen sales conversations become noticeably smoother when contractors begin understanding their clients’ challenges and communicating their expertise effectively.

Prospective clients become more engaged. They ask better questions, volunteer information about future projects, and sometimes say something as simple as, “You really get what we’re trying to accomplish.”

That feedback is significant because instead of spending every conversation defending its price or qualifications, the contractor is becoming a trusted resource.

You can also feel momentum developing inside the company. Employees become more confident in the strategy, project teams better understand the work they’re trying to win, and business development conversations become more productive.

These are encouraging signs, but they aren’t substitutes for financial performance. A verbal indication of interest isn’t an awarded contract, and a promising relationship isn’t guaranteed revenue.

Record these developments in your CRM, connect them to specific accounts and opportunities, and monitor whether they eventually convert into profitable projects.

Client and Employee Retention Belong on the Scorecard

The transition to better work should improve more than the project pipeline. It should strengthen the relationships that make the business sustainable.

Repeat clients often trust your company enough that they’re less inclined to seek competing bids, even if they continue considering other contractors. That reduces some of the competitive pressure associated with unfamiliar clients and public bidding.

But repeat revenue alone isn’t enough. As we discussed in Part 8, a large client can provide substantial revenue while still being difficult to work with or consistently delivering poor margins.

Measure client retention, repeat-client profitability, referrals, and whether clients increasingly involve your company before projects are formally bid. Client surveys and Net Promoter Score (NPS) can also provide valuable insights into the experience you’re delivering.

Employee retention deserves equal attention. If the company is consistently winning projects with unrealistic schedules, inadequate margins, or unreasonable clients, employees may bear the consequences.

Better work should create opportunities for people to develop, contribute their expertise, and take pride in the projects they’re delivering. Monitor employee retention, engagement, and feedback alongside financial results.

Client and employee satisfaction won’t always move in the same direction as profitability, but persistent deterioration in either should prompt leadership to investigate.

When Margins Compress, Investigate Before Changing Strategy

Imagine a contractor with record revenue, an expanding pipeline, and more negotiated opportunities than ever before. Business development is pleased with the results, but net profit margins are declining.

What’s happening? It could be an estimating problem. Perhaps the company is underpricing work or failing to account for project risks. It might be an operational problem involving productivity, scheduling, staffing, or project management. Competition may be intensifying, or material costs may be rising faster than estimates anticipated.

The answer shouldn’t be for BD to celebrate revenue growth while operations and finance struggle with profitability. Marketing, business development, estimating, and operations are on the same team. Their success should be measured by the company’s overall performance.

Leadership needs to investigate the causes of margin compression and determine what adjustments are necessary. That may involve revising estimating assumptions, changing pricing strategies, adjusting target markets, improving project execution, or becoming more selective about opportunities.

Sometimes the problem originates outside the company, which makes strong client relationships even more valuable.

Tariffs Show Why Strong Relationships Matter

I’ve seen contractors face difficult conversations when tariffs and changing material costs compressed project margins. Trade policy changes in 2024, followed by additional tariff measures in 2025, created uncertainty around certain imported construction materials.

FMI’s analysis of the 2025 tariff changes emphasized potential effects on construction costs, supply chains, pricing, and margins. It also recommended clear client communication and flexible approaches to managing project challenges.

Source: FMI, The 2025 Tariff Resurgence: What It Means for Contractors.

These are situations where relationships become particularly valuable. A contractor with little connection to the client may struggle to explain why its original pricing assumptions have changed.

A contractor that has developed trust can have a more productive conversation about material costs, procurement timelines, alternative products, and possible adjustments.

That doesn’t mean clients will automatically agree to higher prices. Existing contracts may limit the contractor’s ability to recover increased costs, and some owners face their own budget constraints. But strong relationships create opportunities for transparent discussions and collaborative problem-solving.

I’ve seen contractors rely on that trust when unexpected cost increases threatened margins. Rather than hiding the problem or simply absorbing every cost increase, they could explain the situation, provide supporting information, and work with clients to evaluate options.

The lesson goes beyond tariffs. Material shortages, labor constraints, schedule disruptions, and changing market conditions will continue affecting construction projects.

Contractors need financial discipline, accurate estimating, appropriate contractual protections, and strong operational execution. They also need relationships that can withstand difficult conversations.

A Practical Executive Scorecard

I recommend beginning with a manageable dashboard that the CEO, CFO, marketing, business development, and operations leaders can review together.

Metric Suggested Review
Net profit margin and project margin trends Monthly financial review; quarterly trends
Project mix by delivery and selection method Quarterly
Proposal count, hit rate, and average project size Monthly and quarterly
ICP scores, account tiers, and Go/No-Go outcomes Monthly
Qualified pipeline, backlog, and early-involvement opportunities Monthly
Repeat-client revenue, profitability, and referrals Quarterly
Client and employee retention and feedback Quarterly, with annual trend review

The dashboard should reflect the company’s size, work types, and reporting capabilities. A contractor with long-duration projects may need to evaluate results over several quarters rather than drawing conclusions from one month’s performance.

It’s also important to distinguish project gross margin from company net profit margin.

Gross margin helps identify whether individual projects are being estimated and executed profitably. Net profit margin shows whether the company retains sufficient earnings after overhead and other expenses.

A project can perform well while corporate overhead erodes net profitability. Conversely, an attractive companywide margin may temporarily conceal underperforming projects. Both perspectives matter.

CFMA’s Construction Financial Benchmarker offers useful peer comparisons for construction profitability, liquidity, leverage, and efficiency. Its 2025 analysis included 1,558 companies after data screening.

Benchmarks provide context, but your company’s performance should also be evaluated against its own historical results, business model, and strategic objectives.

Source: CFMA, Construction Financial Benchmarker.

Don’t Abandon a Sound Strategy Because Results Take Time

What happens when a contractor has spent a year improving its positioning, developing targeted relationships, and becoming more selective, but negotiated awards and net profit haven’t improved yet?

I wouldn’t automatically recommend changing direction. First, examine whether the company is developing meaningful relationships with the right prospective clients.

Are conversations improving? Are clients recognizing the contractor’s expertise? Are decision-makers inviting the company into earlier project discussions?

If the answers are yes, the strategy may be building momentum that hasn’t yet appeared in awarded projects or financial results. In that situation, I’d recommend doubling down on relationships and expertise rather than abandoning the approach out of impatience.

Continue helping prospective clients solve problems, sharing useful insights, and demonstrating the advantages of involving your company earlier.

But don’t confuse persistence with refusing to learn. If targeted clients consistently don’t value your expertise, the company has no realistic competitive advantage, or the available projects cannot meet its financial requirements, leadership should reevaluate the strategy.

Similarly, if stronger relationships produce more work but margins continue deteriorating, investigate the underlying business problems instead of assuming marketing or business development alone can solve them.

The goal is continuous improvement, not blind commitment to a plan.

The Ultimate Measurement Is a Better Construction Company

Throughout this series, we’ve explored how contractors can reduce their dependence on low-bid competition. We’ve discussed choosing better clients, developing meaningful differentiation, building relationships before opportunities are bid, contributing expertise during preconstruction, aligning internal departments, and creating client experiences that earn repeat business.

None of those activities operates independently. A strong brand won’t compensate for poor project execution. Excellent operations won’t generate enough opportunities if desirable clients don’t know the company exists. Strong BD relationships won’t produce sustainable growth if estimating and operations cannot deliver profitable projects.

The transition is a coordinated business strategy, and its results need to be measured accordingly.

Success may look different for every contractor. One company might increase negotiated work significantly. Another may improve its win rate and profitability while maintaining a substantial portfolio of competitive projects.

Both can be successful if they’re becoming more selective, financially healthy, and attractive to clients and employees.

The goal isn’t to win every project or eliminate low-bid work. It’s to build a construction company that consistently wins better work, serves better-fit clients, retains talented employees, and earns healthier profit margins.

That’s how you know the transition is working.

From Low Bid to Preferred Contractor: The Series Conclusion

Moving away from competing primarily on price is not a quick marketing campaign. It’s a long-term business transformation that requires leadership commitment, operational discipline, and a willingness to develop real relationships with clients.

The contractors that succeed won’t simply become better at selling their services. They’ll become better companies to hire, work with, and trust.

Your Next Negotiated Project May Come From Your Last Client

Construction companies invest heavily in proposals, estimating, marketing, and BD to win new projects. Then they award the job to operations and start hunting for the next one, sometimes overlooking the client they just convinced to hire them.

Existing clients already know how your people communicate, handle problems, and make their jobs easier or harder. Those experiences influence repeat business, referrals, and invitations to participate in projects before they go out to bid. But repeat work doesn’t happen automatically, and a satisfied client isn’t necessarily a loyal one.

Quality Work Gets You Hired. Experience Gets You Rehired.

Safety, quality, schedule, and budget performance are baseline expectations. They’re essential, but meeting them doesn’t guarantee a client will want another project with your team. In client interviews, I’ve repeatedly heard buyers emphasize how a contractor made them feel: whether the team listened, communicated proactively, solved problems, and reduced stress.

That distinction is reflected in the SMPS Foundation’s 2026 research on client experience in the AEC industry, developed with ClearlyRated. Client experience deserves attention as an organizational capability, not merely a marketing campaign. A difficult project can still result in a strong relationship when the contractor handles problems transparently and professionally; good technical work alone may not repair a miserable working relationship.

The Details Clients Remember

Demo Diva, the demolition and dumpster company known for its pink equipment, understands that customer experience begins with empathy. Its team doesn’t just take an order. It helps people determine where a dumpster may legally be placed, explains the process, and recognizes that demolishing or cleaning out a family home can be emotional. The bright branding gets attention, but the care people experience makes the company distinctive.

I’ve seen the same lesson at much greater scale. At a billion-dollar general contractor, we discovered that the receptionist was creating such a negative first impression that inbound prospects were being driven away. We changed who answered the phones and greeted visitors, making those interactions more professional and welcoming. Over the following year, we attributed approximately 10% revenue growth to that improvement. Other growth efforts were underway as well, but fixing a neglected customer touchpoint made a significant difference.

Neither example is about a complicated software platform or flashy campaign. It’s about understanding that every employee who interacts with a customer affects whether someone wants to work with the company.

Design the Experience Instead of Leaving It to Chance

I’m working with a residential contractor to map its desired client experience, from small repairs to million-dollar renovations. The level of personal attention naturally differs, but three principles remain constant: communication, transparency, and trust. We’re introducing small touches such as handwritten notes and thoughtful gifts, while putting far more attention into updates, expectations, and resolving issues promptly.

A great project manager may already deliver that experience, but the company shouldn’t depend on a handful of naturally personable employees. Document the important touchpoints from first call and kickoff through construction, closeout, and aftercare. Set standards employees can consistently deliver, then allow room for personal touches that feel genuine.

Ask for feedback throughout the project, not just when it’s over. Questions such as “What could we be doing better?” can uncover frustration while there’s still time to respond. After closeout, when a client is pleased with the outcome, marketing can coordinate requests for testimonials, case studies, referrals, or Google reviews. Operations must address the underlying experience; marketing’s role is to make feedback and follow-up consistent.

Turn Satisfied Clients Into Loyal Advocates

There’s a difference between a client who is satisfied, one who prefers to work with you again, and one who recommends you to others. FMI has cautioned that repeat business alone doesn’t prove loyalty: a customer may return because of price, convenience, or a lack of alternatives.

A loyal client trusts your team and wants to work together again. An advocate takes the next step by recommending your company, providing references, or making introductions. Those introductions are especially valuable when you’re pursuing more negotiated work, because trust can precede the first proposal.

Don’t assume the relationship will survive on its own after final payment. Develop a tiered retention program with assigned relationship owners, planned calls or meetings, and company-wide communications such as newsletters and holiday cards. The higher-priority the client, the more personalized the contact should be.

I recently worked with a specialty contractor’s VP of Commercial Construction to establish a prioritized client schedule, including taking a GC client to lunch each week. I also coached him on how to talk confidently, but humbly, about his team’s accomplishments and respond to questions about a low-priced competitor without disparaging them. The goal was to keep relationships growing and make the team’s value easier to recognize.

GCs and Trades Need Different Relationship Plans

A GC may deliver one major facility for an owner who won’t build again for years. In that case, staying in touch can create referrals, future renovations, or introductions to other owners. Specialty contractors may have more frequent opportunities because their GC clients manage many projects each year.

Trades should expand relationships beyond one estimator or project manager within each GC and make sure the broader organization understands their capabilities. If a GC knows you only for roofing, it may overlook your exterior envelope or siding work. A short case study and a thoughtful introduction may open more doors than simply asking to be added to another bid list.

Marketing can build the retention calendar, coordinate communication, capture feedback, and identify opportunities for account expansion. BD and project leadership still own personal relationships, while operations delivers the experience that earns trust. A newsletter cannot replace a call from the project executive, and no holiday gift will fix poor execution.

Start With Your Last Five Clients

Review five recently completed projects and ask whether each client would hire you again. More importantly, ask what evidence supports that answer. Have you gathered feedback, assigned a relationship owner, discussed future needs, and planned the next meaningful touchpoint?

Measure repeat-client work, referrals, client retention, and feedback such as Net Promoter Score, keeping in mind that small construction client samples can be noisy. Look for invitations to participate earlier and relationships that extend beyond one contact. Those are signs you’re becoming a preferred contractor rather than simply a familiar bidder.

Your next negotiated project may not come from a more expensive proposal campaign. It may come from someone who already trusts your people and would be glad to work with them again.


Next in the Series: How to Measure Your Transition From Low Bid to Negotiated Work

Winning more negotiated projects is an important goal, but how do you know whether the strategy is working? In the final article, we’ll examine the business development, financial, and client relationship metrics that reveal whether your company is winning better work, improving profit margins, and building a healthier project pipeline.

Why Marketing, BD, Estimating, and Operations Must Work Together

I’ve worked with construction companies where marketing created materials the business development team didn’t want, while BD complained it lacked the tools it needed. Frustrated salespeople made their own presentations using outdated logos and inconsistent messaging. Meanwhile, estimating and operations disagreed with BD about which projects deserved attention, and internal friction sometimes undermined proposals.

These weren’t necessarily lazy or incapable people. They were often working hard toward different definitions of success. A contractor can’t become a preferred partner if its own departments aren’t aligned on the clients, projects, and outcomes worth pursuing.

Agree on the Work You Actually Want

BD may spend years cultivating a relationship, only to find that the eventual project has an unrealistic schedule, unacceptable risk, or inadequate margin. Estimating doesn’t want to waste resources pursuing it, while operations lacks the crews or project leadership to deliver. BD worries that declining will damage a hard-earned relationship. Each concern is legitimate, but the decision has to serve the company, not a departmental scoreboard.

I’ve long maintained that bringing in low-margin work or bad-fit clients can be worse than bringing in no new work. A strategic exception might make sense for entering a market or strengthening a valuable relationship, but it should be deliberate, with leadership understanding the tradeoffs.

Start by getting executives, marketing, BD, estimating/preconstruction, and operations to agree on ideal clients, target markets, minimum project requirements, and the capabilities that make the company competitive. Marketing and BD contribute customer and market intelligence. Preconstruction evaluates fit and project economics. Operations determines delivery capacity. Leadership reconciles the perspectives into a realistic growth plan.

Once those decisions are made, the team can develop a coordinated approach to target accounts: relationships, educational content, events, direct mail, or narrowly targeted digital campaigns. Those activities should support the same clients and business objectives, not compete for attention.

Marketing Belongs in the Strategy Conversation

Too many contractors treat marketing as an internal production department. Executives pick the markets, BD selects prospects, and marketing is asked to make a webpage, brochure, or campaign. Those tools matter, but a strategic marketing leader should help the company decide where to compete and why a client should choose it.

Consider a GC interested in healthcare construction. Before launching an advertising campaign, a CMO should help investigate the segments with attractive demand, the problems owners face, competitors’ positioning, how projects are procured, and which buyer relationships matter. The team then tests those opportunities against its operational experience and capacity. Only after those decisions should marketing build the messaging, authority content, and account-based programs that support market entry.

I’ve helped contractors select target markets, develop account strategies, package offerings, and identify competitive advantages based on customer research. Marketing can also bring client feedback to leadership when it reveals gaps in service or opportunities for new capabilities. It shouldn’t dictate construction methods or override estimating, but it should influence the business decisions that shape growth, not simply promote them afterward.

Make Brand Promises Everyone Can Deliver

A contractor’s ideal client profile, differentiation, brand personality, and central story should be developed together, not handed from one department to another. A client-focused framework such as StoryBrand can help clarify the customer’s challenges and the outcomes the company delivers, but the promises must reflect actual capabilities and culture.

If marketing claims the company is a collaborative problem-solver while project teams communicate poorly or treat change orders as an adversarial contest, clients will remember the experience rather than the message. Brand is not just the story marketing tells. It’s what clients experience when dealing with estimating, project leadership, field crews, and the front office.

Use Go/No-Go to Make Decisions, Not Start Fights

In Part 3, we discussed scored Go/No-Go decisions as a way to improve pursuit discipline. The BD professional or estimator closest to an opportunity can perform the initial evaluation, looking at client fit, relevant experience, competition, potential margin, risk, and operational capacity. Strong opportunities proceed, weak ones are declined, and gray-area pursuits receive executive review.

That process protects relationships and resources because everyone understands how decisions are made. It shouldn’t give BD permission to chase everything, estimating permission to reject unfamiliar work automatically, or operations an excuse to resist every growth initiative. When there is disagreement, leadership makes the call and explains its business rationale.

Bring Operations Into the Pursuit and Preserve the Handoff

Project managers and superintendents understand schedule realism, manpower, site logistics, and the consequences of assumptions made before award. FMI’s 2025 Project Management Study reported that firms involving project managers in estimating met profit-margin targets 78% of the time, compared with 55% among firms that did not. That’s an association, not proof that attending one meeting produces better margins, but it supports earlier collaboration.

The collaboration can’t stop at award. BD and preconstruction may know about a client’s previous contractor frustrations, communication preferences, concerns about disruption, and promises made during selection. A project kickoff should transfer those details alongside scope, schedule, estimating assumptions, and contractual responsibilities. Otherwise, operations may deliver the technical project while repeating the exact client-experience problems the company promised to solve.

Project teams also hear about future needs and see opportunities to demonstrate expertise. Their first obligation is to execute the work well, but they should share client insights with the people responsible for relationships and marketing. That feedback helps the company improve future pursuits, case studies, and service offerings.

Measure Outcomes the Departments Share

BD commissions and activity metrics can unintentionally reward the wrong work. A BD professional who cultivated a client for years may hesitate to recommend declining a poor-fit opportunity; estimating may be judged on bid volume, while marketing reports leads regardless of quality. Everyone can hit departmental targets while company margins and employee morale decline.

Executives need a shared view of qualified opportunities, pursuit win rates, actual versus estimated project margins, repeat-client business, client satisfaction, and employee retention. Individual teams still need their own operating metrics, but no one should celebrate revenue growth while operations and finance are left managing unprofitable projects.

FMI’s 2026 project management research also found a wide gap between firms reporting formal playbooks and those applying them consistently. Having a process is different from making it how the company works.

When the CEO Chases the Next Shiny Object

I’ve repeatedly seen leadership teams agree on growth priorities, only for an impatient CEO to become excited about an unrelated market or project. Suddenly marketing is researching new prospects, BD is chasing different relationships, and estimating and operations are being pulled away from their commitments. Yet everyone is still measured against the original plan.

Entrepreneurial instincts can create worthwhile opportunities, and a growth strategy must adapt when conditions change. But the CEO cannot treat the plan as optional while expecting everyone else to follow it. Before pursuing a major exception, ask: Why is this better than our current priorities? What work or resources must shift? Who owns the decision and how will we judge success? If the new opportunity wins, revise the plan openly and stop pretending the team can execute both priorities with the same capacity.

Start With Alignment, Not Another Meeting

I wouldn’t begin by adding another standing meeting. I’d get leaders aligned on three fundamentals: ideal clients and target markets, meaningful differentiation and brand personality, and a clear client-focused story. Then I’d establish Go/No-Go decisions, joint pursuit planning, project kickoffs, relationship ownership, and a small number of shared measures.

Marketing helps the company understand the market and communicate value. BD develops relationships, estimating tests project economics, and operations delivers the experience that earns repeat work. Leadership is accountable for keeping those efforts aligned. A contractor doesn’t win better work because each department performs well in isolation; it wins when the company makes better decisions together.


Next in the Series: Your Next Negotiated Project May Come From Your Last Client

Winning a project is only the beginning of a valuable client relationship. In Part 8, we’ll explore how contractors turn excellent project delivery, proactive communication, and memorable client experiences into repeat business, referrals, and future negotiated opportunities.

Win the Project Before It’s Designed: Selling Preconstruction and Design-Assist Value

In traditional competitive bidding, contractors often arrive after major decisions are set. The design is developed, materials have been selected, and the owner has expectations about budget and schedule. Then the construction team is asked to price a plan that might contain avoidable problems or costly assumptions.

I’ve seen contractors create far more value when they’re involved before those decisions become difficult to change. Early construction expertise can improve schedules, material choices, site logistics, procurement, durability, and the owner’s overall investment. The opportunity isn’t merely to win a different kind of contract. It’s to become someone the client wants involved while the project is taking shape.

Value Engineering Should Improve Outcomes, Not Just Cut Costs

Good value engineering looks beyond finding cheaper materials. A longer-reach concrete pump can reduce costly equipment repositioning. Early identification of long-lead HVAC equipment can change procurement and sequencing decisions before delays become inevitable. Alternative construction systems can improve durability or installation efficiency, provided they’re appropriate for the project and meet performance requirements.

One roofing and siding contractor I worked with demonstrated what happens when the conversation expands beyond an individual trade bid. Rather than price only a roof or siding package, the contractor evaluated the full exterior and recommended a Class 4 impact-resistant roof with a 50-year warranty and stronger wind and fire ratings, particularly valuable in that region.

The upgraded roof cost more, so the team identified savings through alternative siding and mortarless stone wall systems. The contractor secured approximately three times the original scope and contract value while saving the owner about $200,000 compared with the alternative approach. The roof also reduced the owner’s insurance premiums for several years, though such discounts depend on the product, insurer, and policy.

The contractor didn’t create a larger project by cutting its markup. It expanded its scope by helping the owner make better decisions about the entire exterior. That is a powerful reason for owners to involve trusted contractors early.

Research from the Construction Industry Institute on front-end planning reinforces the value of thoughtful early decisions. Its findings concern front-end planning broadly, not a guaranteed savings percentage from any particular preconstruction service.

Preconstruction Is a Service, Not Just a Free Estimate

Many contractors already perform pieces of preconstruction: conceptual budgets, schedules, sequencing, procurement planning, site logistics, safety plans, and constructability reviews. Often, the work is spread among estimators, project managers, superintendents, and key trade partners. Packaging those capabilities into a defined service helps an owner understand what it receives and why it matters.

A healthcare project might require early planning around infection control and active operations. An industrial project may need construction sequencing that protects production. On complex projects, GCs should bring mechanical, electrical, civil, exterior, and other critical trades into the discussion early enough to influence decisions rather than react to finalized drawings.

I’ve helped both GCs and specialty contractors package these capabilities into clearer preconstruction offerings. The most useful offerings address real owner problems and specify deliverables, responsibilities, and when the team will be involved. They don’t need to begin with a large standalone department.

Know When “Free-Con” Should Become Paid Preconstruction

Contractors jokingly call it “free-con” for a reason. Preliminary estimating and advice are often part of earning a relationship, but repeated budget revisions, detailed logistics, coordination, and design-assist work can become a substantial unpaid engagement.

I’m seeing more projects divide paid preconstruction from construction, sometimes with different contractors performing each phase. The owner pays for valuable planning deliverables, while the contractor is compensated for expertise even if it doesn’t ultimately build the project. This approach isn’t universal, and simple projects may not justify it, but both parties benefit when expectations are clear.

Before significant work begins, define the scope, deliverables, compensation, change process, and how recommendations may be used. For design-assist arrangements, AIA Document C403–2021 offers one framework for engaging consultants. Design-assist and delegated design have different responsibilities, so contractors should confirm contractual and insurance implications with qualified advisors.

Specialty Contractors: Become a Problem-Solver, Not an Order Taker

A specialty contractor often earns earlier involvement by making a GC’s job easier on current projects. Identifying a constructability concern, proposing a durable material alternative, or improving sequencing can demonstrate why your input belongs at the design table. If your ideas save time or prevent problems, the GC has a reason to call before the next package goes out to bid.

There is a legitimate risk, however: a GC may take a subcontractor’s value engineering ideas and ask lower-priced competitors to execute them. Don’t give away an extensive design-assist effort without discussing expectations and the appropriate use of your work. The goal isn’t to charge for every useful suggestion, but to build relationships that respect specialized expertise.

An order taker can be interchangeable. A trusted trade partner who consistently improves project outcomes is much harder to replace.

Prove the Value Before You Promote the Service

Construction websites and proposals often list square footage, contract value, and materials installed without explaining the contractor’s contribution. For preconstruction, that misses the most persuasive part of the story. Did your team flag a long-lead item, improve sequencing, reduce disruption, or propose an alternative with better life-cycle performance?

Interview estimators, project managers, superintendents, and clients to document what was prevented or improved, then turn those examples into case studies. Use verified numbers when available, and credit the design team and trade partners involved. Specific challenges and outcomes are more persuasive than another claim that your company provides “value engineering.”

A strategic CMO can also help identify which owner problems justify a preconstruction offering, define the value proposition with operational leaders, and create educational content that explains the benefits of early involvement. Marketing can open the conversation, but preconstruction and project leaders must deliver the technical expertise.

Start Where Your Expertise Makes a Difference

Not every project needs extensive preconstruction. A straightforward, repetitive project may offer little opportunity to improve the design, while a client focused exclusively on lowest price may not value additional planning. Use Go/No-Go discipline to consider complexity, client fit, project viability, and whether the resources required are justified.

Start with three recent projects where earlier construction input improved, or could have improved, the result. Document the challenge, recommendation, and effect on cost, schedule, risk, or performance. Share those lessons with architects, prospective clients, and trusted partners. The aim isn’t to give away more expertise in hopes of winning a bid; it’s to demonstrate why qualified contractors deserve a seat at the table before the design is complete.


Next in the Series: Why Marketing, BD, Estimating, and Operations Must Work Together

Getting involved earlier requires more than talented estimators and good client relationships. In Part 7, we’ll explore how contractors align marketing, business development, estimating, and operations around a shared growth strategy so they can consistently win and deliver better work.

From Bid List to Shortlist: How Contractors Earn More Negotiated Opportunities

Most contractors would welcome more calls from owners or GCs asking them to discuss an upcoming project rather than submit another competitive bid. But becoming a preferred contractor doesn’t happen because you ask to be added to a shortlist. It happens when decision-makers already know your company, trust your expertise, and believe you’ll make their projects better.

Too many business development conversations revolve around the same question: “Do you have anything coming up that we can bid?” There’s nothing wrong with asking, but relationships built entirely around requests for work rarely create the preference contractors want. You have to understand the business behind the project.

Become an Expert in Your Client’s Business

I worked with a contractor that wanted to become a preferred builder for freestanding urgent care centers and emergency rooms. Rather than chase every healthcare bid, he spent about six months learning the market. He met with doctors, nurses, healthcare architects, and facility managers, attended conferences and webinars, and studied infection control, patient flow, and the economics of those facilities.

He became knowledgeable enough to discuss how construction decisions affected healthcare operations, not just budgets and schedules. Over time, he became a go-to contractor for those facilities within roughly a two-hour radius. He hadn’t become the cheapest bidder. He had become someone clients and influencers trusted to understand their problems.

That’s the difference between showing up when plans are ready and establishing credibility while a project is still taking shape. Construction expertise matters, but knowledge of the client’s business can be what earns the first meaningful conversation.

Use the Next Man Up Strategy

Many owners have established contractor relationships, and good specialty trades may work with the same GCs for decades. A single meeting won’t displace that trust. I use what I call the Next Man Up Strategy: become a credible alternative before a client needs one.

Stay in touch, learn their priorities, share relevant expertise, and look for opportunities to help without turning every interaction into a sales pitch. The incumbent might become unavailable, the client might enter a new market, or a future project may require different capabilities. When circumstances change, you want to be the contractor they already know and respect.

Not every relationship deserves years of investment. If there’s little strategic fit or no realistic path to an opportunity, apply the same Go/No-Go discipline you’d use for a project pursuit.

Build a Short, Tiered Target List

Relationship development should be personal, but it shouldn’t be random. I recommend starting with approximately five Tier 1 accounts, 10–15 Tier 2 accounts, and 25–35 Tier 3 accounts, adjusting to the size of your market and the team’s capacity. Focus the most individualized effort on the clients whose projects, values, and growth plans match your ideal client profile.

For Tier 1 targets, identify decision-makers and influencers, understand business priorities, study their project history, and assign a relationship owner. Use your CRM to record what matters to each person and schedule meaningful follow-ups. Digital advertising, direct mail, events, and targeted content can reinforce familiarity, but none substitutes for a real conversation.

When you meet someone, ask about their priorities, operational challenges, future plans, and frustrations with previous projects. Lunch or coffee can be productive, but the goal is to become useful, not to rack up networking activities. The best BD style is one that suits both the person building the relationship and the clients you’re trying to reach.

Give Prospects a Reason to Engage

Construction companies have valuable knowledge that rarely leaves the jobsite. Project managers, estimators, superintendents, and specialty experts solve problems involving materials, sequencing, procurement, and occupied facilities every day. Marketing can turn that knowledge into case studies, educational content, technical presentations, and tools that make conversations more valuable.

A useful article about avoiding schedule disruptions in healthcare renovations is more likely to engage a hospital facilities leader than another generic company announcement. A specialty trade may earn an earlier invitation by bringing a GC a practical constructability idea rather than simply explaining its services.

Marketing should research what target accounts care about and package credible expertise. Business development should use that material to deepen relationships, not just to drive website traffic. Technical leaders should participate when their judgment can help the client make a better decision.

Expand Relationships Beyond One Contact

GCs need relationships with owners, developers, architects, facilities professionals, and referral partners such as bankers, attorneys, and economic development organizations. Those people may know about expansions and capital projects before a formal procurement process begins.

Specialty contractors often have a smaller universe of target GCs, but the same principle applies inside each account. I’ve seen trade contractors depend heavily on a single estimator or project manager. If that person moves on, the relationship can disappear. Deliberately meet other preconstruction leaders, project executives, and decision-makers, and show them the full range of your capabilities. Adding just one meaningful GC relationship each month compounds over time.

The owner, BD professional, and project executive should have clear relationship responsibilities. Everyone contributes to reputation, but someone must own the next touchpoint. Public-sector outreach must also respect procurement restrictions, especially during active solicitations.

Your First 90 Days

Days 1–30: Choose your target accounts, tier them, research their decision-makers, and identify existing introductions.
Days 31–60: Start conversations, ask better questions, and learn how those organizations evaluate contractors.
Days 61–90: Share useful expertise, introduce technical people when appropriate, and establish a consistent follow-up cadence.

Measure early progress through stronger contacts, meetings with decision-makers, invitations to participate earlier, and new information about planned projects. Don’t expect a fully negotiated pipeline in 90 days. The objective is to become the contractor clients think of before they need another bid.


Next in the Series: Win the Project Before It’s Designed: Selling Preconstruction and Design-Assist Value

Building relationships creates opportunities for earlier involvement, but contractors still need to demonstrate how their expertise improves project outcomes. In Part 6, we’ll explore how preconstruction, design-assist, constructability reviews, and technical collaboration help contractors create value before construction begins.

What Makes Your Contractor Worth More Than the Lowest Bidder?

Ask a construction executive what makes their company different, and you’ll usually hear some version of quality work, experienced people, safety, and on-time, on-budget delivery. Those things matter, but almost every competitor makes the same claims. If buyers can’t see a meaningful difference, price becomes the easiest way to compare you.

I’ve also met contractors who genuinely don’t recognize their own strengths. What makes them valuable feels so normal to their employees that nobody thinks to mention it. The challenge isn’t inventing a clever slogan. It’s discovering where your company creates value that clients recognize and competitors struggle to match.

Your Differentiation May Be Hiding in Plain Sight

I once worked with a contractor whose leadership and management team largely came from military special operations. They didn’t think that background was remarkable; it was simply their culture. Yet they were exceptionally comfortable with ambiguity, complicated projects, and solving unexpected problems, while they disliked heavily administrative work with little room for initiative.

That insight changed more than their marketing message. It helped define the projects they should pursue, their competitive positioning, and their Go/No-Go decisions. They didn’t need to be the right contractor for everyone. They needed to find clients whose challenges matched their strengths.

Differentiation is the intersection of what you do especially well and what your ideal clients value. It might be a specialized capability, an unusual project experience, faster coordination, or a team that’s exceptionally good at navigating difficult circumstances.

Ask Clients Why They Choose You

One of my favorite ways to discover differentiation is to interview customers. I start with two questions: “Why did you select us?” and “Why do you continue to work with us?” The answers often differ from what a contractor’s leadership team expects.

A company might promote its technical credentials, while clients talk about how its project managers keep them informed and solve problems without drama. Another might emphasize decades of experience, while buyers remember a creative solution that prevented downtime. With permission, those observations become credible testimonials, case studies, and proposal stories. Interviews with prospects you nearly won can be just as useful because they reveal why you made the shortlist but lost the selection.

The objective isn’t to collect compliments. It’s to understand the problems clients will pay to have solved, then prove your company has solved them before.

Relevant Expertise Can Beat Size and Price

I worked with two brothers whose construction company specialized in healthcare facilities, including additions involving MRI and CT equipment. They competed against firms roughly 20 times their size and still won projects when their bids were about 10% higher. Their advantage was an understanding of complex healthcare work, sensitive operations, and specialized equipment that made clients more confident in their approach.

I’ve seen something similar with a commercial specialty contractor that regularly won despite pricing approximately 7–15% above a low-cost competitor. General contractors valued its coordination, ability to solve problems, and success keeping difficult projects moving. Delays, rework, and constant supervision can cost considerably more than the difference on the bid tab.

Those examples don’t mean every contractor can charge a 10% premium. They demonstrate that the right expertise and a better working relationship can outweigh a lower initial price when the buyer understands the benefits. Research on subcontractor selection, including a Clemson University study of large southeastern GCs, identifies experience, past performance, manpower, and scope knowledge among the factors considered beyond price.

Client Experience Is Part of the Value

Construction clients aren’t just buying the finished facility. They’re selecting people they’ll work with for months or years, often under pressure. In client interviews, I repeatedly hear appreciation for teams that communicate proactively, explain tradeoffs, collaborate with other parties, and bring solutions instead of surprises.

Demo Diva offers a useful illustration. Its hot-pink demolition equipment makes the company memorable, but customers choose it for more than a distinctive look. The company’s expertise, personality, and attentiveness to the people behind each project turn recognition into preference. Branding gets a contractor noticed; the experience gives someone a reason to hire it again.

Quality, safety, and schedule reliability remain important. But a claim such as “committed to safety” isn’t proof. Document verified results, describe the practices behind them, and show how those practices reduce client risk. Client testimonials and repeat-business figures can support the same argument, provided the numbers are real and the measurement method is clear.

Marketing Should Help Create Value, Not Just Describe It

This is where strategic marketing has a larger role than producing brochures and proposals. Customer interviews and competitive research can reveal opportunities to improve the contractor’s offering, not merely its messaging. I’ve helped contractors identify new services, package existing expertise, and strengthen the client experience based on what buyers actually value.

A developer pursuing earlier occupancy may prioritize schedule certainty, while an owner expecting to operate a facility for decades may care more about durability and maintenance. A GC choosing a specialty contractor may be focused on manpower, coordination, and minimizing disruption to other trades. Your advantage must be relevant to the specific client, not just impressive to your own leadership team.

Start with a simple exercise: have your leadership team name three competitive strengths, then ask several recent clients why they selected you and whether they’d hire you again. Compare the answers. Where they differ, explore whether the company should communicate differently, improve its operations, or build a more valuable offering.

Give Clients a Reason to Choose You

Some construction work will always be awarded primarily on price, and there’s nothing wrong with competing for it when you can do so profitably. But if you want more negotiated and preferred-contractor opportunities, clients must understand what they’ll gain by choosing you before they review the final number.

The strongest differentiation isn’t a marketing claim. It’s a valuable capability, backed by evidence, that makes the right client confident your company is worth selecting.


Next in the Series: From Bid List to Shortlist: How Contractors Earn More Negotiated Opportunities

Understanding your differentiation is only the beginning. In Part 5, we’ll explore how contractors use that competitive advantage to build relationships earlier, earn consideration before projects go out to bid, and become preferred partners rather than another name on the bid list.

Stop Bidding Everything: Find the Construction Work Worth Winning

I’ve worked with construction companies that proudly discuss how many projects they bid each year. Their estimating departments are constantly busy, their bid calendars are packed, and they’re pursuing hundreds of millions of dollars in potential work.

But when I ask how many of those projects they realistically expect to win, the conversation often changes.

Contractors sometimes operate under the assumption that more bids produce more wins. It sounds logical. More attempts should mean more opportunities for success, right?

That thinking overlooks one critical factor: time.

Every hour your estimator spends on a project you have little chance of winning is an hour they cannot spend on a better opportunity. The same applies to your proposal specialists, business development team, preconstruction professionals, and executives.

Bidding more projects doesn’t necessarily increase your chances of winning more work. Sometimes, it actually hurts them.

Your Best Opportunity May Be the Project You’re Neglecting

Imagine your company has two opportunities sitting on the estimating department’s desk.

The first is a competitive bid where you estimate a 5% chance of winning. You don’t know the client particularly well, have limited insight into the project’s challenges, and expect significant competition.

The second offers a 35% chance of winning. You have relevant experience, a relationship with the client, and a clearer understanding of what matters to the decision-makers.

Your estimators are already busy. Should you pursue both projects simply because you’ve been invited?

The first opportunity isn’t necessarily worthless. It could have strategic value or be relatively easy to estimate. But if pursuing it takes significant time away from the second opportunity, you may be hurting your chances of winning the better project.

What happens if your team uses that additional time to develop more accurate estimates, evaluate alternative approaches, coordinate with subcontractors, or strengthen its proposal for the higher-probability opportunity?

You might improve your chances of winning. You might also identify risks that help you avoid an unprofitable project.

There are no guarantees, but the principle is important: Your estimating and proposal capacity is finite.

Contractors who bid everything often spread their resources across too many opportunities instead of giving the most attractive projects the attention they deserve.

The Hidden Cost of Bidding Everything

Estimating and proposal development aren’t free. Contractors pay for those activities through salaries, benefits, technology, subcontractor coordination, travel, and other overhead expenses.

A 2026 analysis published by construction software company Buildr estimated that a substantial commercial GC pursuit could cost $8,000 to $12,000 or more, depending on the resources involved.

Let’s use $10,000 per pursuit as an example.

If your company submits 100 proposals annually with a 10% win rate, you’ll spend approximately $1 million pursuing those opportunities and win 10 projects.

That’s $100,000 in pursuit costs for every awarded project.

Now imagine becoming more selective about the opportunities you pursue, giving your team more time to develop competitive proposals, and increasing your hit rate to 33%.

At the same $10,000 average cost per pursuit, your pursuit cost per win drops to approximately $30,000.

Bid-hit rate Pursuit cost per win
10% $100,000
20% $50,000
25% $40,000
33% $30,303

 

Increasing your bid-hit rate from 10% to 33% reduces your pursuit cost per win by nearly 70%.

You’re not necessarily asking your estimators to work harder or reducing the resources invested in each proposal. You’re pursuing opportunities where you’re better positioned to succeed.

These figures are illustrative, and actual pursuit costs vary widely depending on the contractor, project size, delivery method, and resources involved. More competitive or complex pursuits may require additional investment.

Nevertheless, the exercise exposes a significant business expense that contractors frequently overlook.

Consider what your company could accomplish with those recovered resources. Your team could invest more time in preconstruction, build stronger client relationships, improve project documentation, pursue higher-value opportunities, or simply work fewer nights and weekends.

The objective isn’t to produce fewer proposals for the sake of producing fewer proposals. It’s to improve the return on your business development and estimating investment.

The Cost to Your Employees Can Be Even Greater

There’s another consequence of constantly pursuing work you don’t win: employee morale.

Imagine spending weeks developing estimates and proposals, working overtime to meet deadlines, and repeatedly watching the company lose projects.

Eventually, employees may begin questioning whether leadership has a realistic growth strategy.

I’ve seen how a constant cycle of low-probability pursuits can wear down marketing, estimating, and business development teams. Their hard work doesn’t produce wins, they rarely have enough time to develop strong submissions, and leadership keeps adding more opportunities to the schedule.

Repeated losses can create a perception that the company simply isn’t competitive.

Unfortunately, winning the wrong projects can be even worse.

A low-margin project with an unreasonable client, unrealistic schedule, or significant construction risks can become miserable for field crews and project managers. Constant disputes, excessive overtime, poorly coordinated work, and financial pressure affect employees long after the estimating team has moved on.

Construction is risky enough without intentionally pursuing clients and projects that create unnecessary problems.

Sometimes the best decision is to let your competitors have the bad client’s bad project.

Stop Evaluating Projects Without Evaluating Clients

A good project with a bad client can be a terrible opportunity. Likewise, a challenging project with an excellent client may be worth pursuing because of the trust, collaboration, and future opportunities involved.

In my book, Choose Your Own Construction Marketing Journey, I introduce a client-ranking system built around five factors I call the 5Rs. I adapted this approach from Kevin Clune’s original 5Rs framework in The MSP Growth Funnel to address the realities of construction companies.

The five factors are:

  1. Revenue: Does the client produce worthwhile, profitable work rather than merely impressive contract values?
  2. Risk: Does working with the client expose your company to unacceptable financial, legal, operational, safety, or reputational risks?
  3. Receivables: Does the client pay reliably, handle change orders reasonably, and respect your billing process?
  4. Referrals: Does the client recommend your company, provide references, and help create additional opportunities?
  5. Relationship: Does the client trust your team, respect your expertise, communicate effectively, and offer potential for future work?

Each client receives a score, allowing the company to identify its best relationships, those with room for improvement, and those that may no longer be worth pursuing.

The larger lesson is that your biggest customer isn’t necessarily your best customer.

A client generating $20 million in annual revenue with thin margins, constant disputes, and frustrated employees may be less valuable than a $5 million client who pays promptly, respects your expertise, and introduces you to other excellent clients.

Understanding which relationships produce the best business outcomes also helps you identify the kinds of clients you should pursue in the future.

Start With a Three-Question Go/No-Go Test

I’ve helped contractors develop comprehensive Go/No-Go evaluation systems, but I often recommend starting with three simple questions.

  1. Do we have relevant experience?

Have we successfully performed similar work, or can we credibly demonstrate that our capabilities translate to this opportunity?

  1. Does the client know our capabilities?

Does the client understand our strengths, relevant experience, technical expertise, and what distinguishes us from other contractors?

  1. Do we understand the client’s real issues and pain points?

Do we know what the client is trying to accomplish, what concerns them, and what factors will influence their decision beyond price?

If you answer no to two or more questions, that’s a strong indication the opportunity deserves additional scrutiny before committing estimating and proposal resources.

This is the fast filter, not the complete evaluation. A contractor entering a new market, for example, may have strategic reasons to pursue an opportunity despite limited existing relationships.

The purpose is to recognize when you’re pursuing work from a position of strength versus simply hoping to win.

Build a Go/No-Go System Your Team Will Actually Use

For more substantial pursuits, I recommend a scored Go/No-Go process containing approximately 10–15 questions.

The scorecard should consider client relationships, project fit, operational capacity, competitive positioning, and financial or strategic value.

A practical 12-question version could evaluate:

Category Questions to evaluate
Client fit Do we have a relationship with decision-makers? Is the client financially reliable and reasonable to work with? Do we understand their needs?
Project fit Does the project align with our experience and target markets? Can it meet our profitability requirements? Are the scope, contract terms, and risks acceptable?
Internal capacity Do we have the necessary project leadership and field resources? Can we meet the proposed schedule? Do we have adequate resources to prepare a competitive pursuit?
Competitive and strategic value Can we demonstrate meaningful differentiation? Do we understand our competition and likelihood of winning? Does this opportunity advance a worthwhile relationship or strategic objective?

 

Score each question from 1 to 5, establish decision thresholds, and adjust the system based on your company’s circumstances.

The business development professional or estimator closest to the opportunity should complete the initial evaluation.

From there, the process should produce one of three decisions:

Go: The opportunity meets established standards, and the team receives approval to pursue it.

No-Go: The opportunity falls below the company’s minimum standards, and resources are redirected elsewhere.

Gray Area: The opportunity requires executive review because its strategic value, competitive situation, backlog implications, or unusual circumstances warrant additional consideration.

Leadership should be involved when judgment is necessary, but shouldn’t have to personally approve every routine pursuit.

Some issues, such as unacceptable safety, legal, or financial exposure, should also trigger a separate risk review rather than being outweighed by an otherwise attractive score.

The process needs to be consistent enough to influence behavior without becoming so complicated that employees stop using it.

And if executives routinely override every No-Go recommendation, the company doesn’t really have a Go/No-Go system. It has a spreadsheet that everyone knows can be ignored.

Don’t Become Too Selective Overnight

A contractor accustomed to bidding everything shouldn’t suddenly reject half its opportunities without considering the consequences.

You still need backlog, cash flow, and enough work to support your people and equipment. Becoming more selective is a transition, not a switch you flip.

I’d recommend starting by reviewing your existing pursuits and identifying patterns. Where are you winning? Which clients produce your strongest margins? Which projects create the most problems? Where are you repeatedly spending resources without success?

Establish an initial minimum Go/No-Go score that reflects your current business conditions. As your relationships strengthen, your backlog improves, and you develop more opportunities aligned with your strategy, gradually raise that threshold.

This helps your company become more selective without unnecessarily jeopardizing short-term revenue.

You’ll also want to evaluate your results. Track win rates by client, market sector, project type, and procurement method. Measure pursuit costs, actual project margins, and how many opportunities originate from established client relationships.

A particularly useful indicator is whether your best opportunities are receiving more attention as your lower-quality pursuits decline.

Winning Better Work Starts With Saying No

Moving from low-bid dependency toward more negotiated and preferred-contractor opportunities requires changing how your company thinks about growth.

The goal isn’t to eliminate competitive bidding. Plenty of contractors earn attractive margins through competitive work, and some public projects must be awarded through legally prescribed low-bid procedures.

The objective is to become intentional about the opportunities you pursue.

That means developing better client relationships, identifying the work you’re best positioned to deliver profitably, understanding your competitive advantages, and giving your teams enough time to pursue attractive projects effectively.

You’ll probably discover that some of your best future opportunities come from clients you already know, while some of your least attractive opportunities come from companies you’ve spent years trying to win.

Revenue alone doesn’t tell you which is which.

Sometimes the best way to win more profitable construction work is to stop bidding projects you shouldn’t be chasing in the first place.


Next in the Series: What Makes Your Contractor Worth More Than the Lowest Bidder?

In Part 4, we’ll explore how contractors identify and prove the expertise, experience, and client benefits that make them worth choosing even when they aren’t the lowest bidder.

Why Your Construction Company Is Stuck Competing on Low Bid

Most construction companies don’t start with a long list of loyal clients willing to negotiate their next project. They start by bidding work, building relationships, proving themselves, and hoping they can deliver projects profitably enough to keep growing.

For a young contractor with limited overhead, competitive bidding can be a practical way to get established. You don’t necessarily need a sophisticated business development department, years of client relationships, or a recognized brand. You need the right qualifications, the ability to estimate and deliver the work, and a competitive price.

For decades, that was how much of the construction industry operated, especially on public projects. Owners hired designers, completed the plans and specifications, and awarded construction contracts to the lowest responsible bidder.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with that approach. In fact, competitive bidding can create excellent opportunities for contractors that understand their costs, manage risk, and execute projects efficiently.

The problem comes when a contractor grows into a $50 million, $100 million, or $250 million company but continues approaching the market like a startup trying to win its first project.

The company has grown up, but its approach to winning work hasn’t.

The Construction Industry Has Evolved. Has Your Business?

Traditional design-bid-build still has an important place in construction, but owners have increasingly embraced delivery methods that allow contractors to participate earlier and contribute more than a competitive price.

According to FMI Consulting’s 2025 Design-Build Utilization Study, design-build represented an estimated 44% of construction spending during 2019–2023 in the market segments studied. Another 37% involved alternative delivery methods, including construction management at risk (CMAR), construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC), engineering-procurement-construction (EPC), and integrated project delivery (IPD).

FMI forecasts design-build’s share rising to 47% during 2024–2028, with other alternative methods accounting for another 42%. These figures represent estimated construction spending in the assessed market segments, not the percentage of all construction projects.

This doesn’t mean every design-build or CMAR project is negotiated. Many involve competitive best-value selection, qualifications evaluations, or other formal procurement requirements.

However, it does demonstrate an important change. In many markets, owners have options that allow them to consider a contractor’s expertise, experience, approach, and ability to create value before construction begins.

Contractors that only know how to compete on price are limiting the opportunities they can realistically pursue.

The Biggest Obstacle Is Often the Contractor’s Mindset

When I talk with contractors about moving toward more negotiated work, the initial discussion usually centers on business development. They believe they need better relationships, more meetings with owners, or someone who can open doors.

Those things certainly help, but the bigger challenge is often how leadership thinks about winning work.

I’ve encountered contractors that obsess over lowering their prices without being able to explain why their services should be worth more. Their proposals describe what they’re going to build, but not the expertise, efficiencies, or risk reduction they bring to the project.

Some genuinely believe low-bid competition is the fairest way to award construction work. Others lack confidence that clients will select them for anything beyond price. They may have spent decades competing successfully through estimating, so it’s difficult to imagine a different approach.

Unfortunately, that mindset can influence decisions throughout the company.

Estimating becomes focused on reducing costs rather than evaluating alternatives that create value. Subcontractor selection emphasizes the lowest number instead of the best combination of price, reliability, quality, and expertise. Business development becomes primarily about finding the next project to bid rather than understanding what clients need.

Eventually, the contractor becomes exceptionally good at competing on price without becoming particularly good at explaining why someone should prefer them.

A Million Dollars Cheaper and Still Lost the Project

More than a decade ago, I helped a civil construction contractor debrief its first public best-value proposal. It was approximately an $8 million project, and the contractor’s leadership couldn’t understand why they lost.

Their price was approximately $1 million less than the winning proposal. They were also roughly three times the size of the joint venture that won the project.

From their perspective, the decision made no sense. They were bigger, had significantly more resources, and were substantially cheaper.

But the public agency wasn’t selecting a contractor based solely on price.

I actually liked the agency’s evaluation process. The selection committee scored the technical proposals without knowing the contractors’ prices. The agency then divided each contractor’s proposed price by its technical score to determine the evaluated result.

My client scored 30 points lower than the winning team.

When we reviewed their proposal, the reason became clearer. They hadn’t meaningfully differentiated themselves, demonstrated their advantages, or explained why they would deliver greater value. Worse, they had skipped entire sections of the proposal, including questions specifically designed to evaluate that value.

They approached a best-value procurement as though submitting a low price would be enough.

Had they answered the questions thoroughly and narrowed the technical-score gap, their substantial price advantage might have made the difference. We can’t know whether they would have won, but they had failed to give the evaluation committee a compelling reason to choose them.

The lesson wasn’t that they needed a better proposal writer. They needed to understand how their prospective client defined value and communicate how their company could deliver it.

Being the cheapest contractor doesn’t automatically make you the best value. And being the largest doesn’t automatically make you the most qualified.

Becoming a Preferred Contractor Means Changing How You Operate

Contractors sometimes approach negotiated work as though it’s simply a different business development strategy. Hire someone with owner relationships, make the right connections, and opportunities will follow.

But becoming a preferred contractor requires more than changing how you sell. It requires evolving what you offer and how clients experience working with your company.

That might mean developing stronger preconstruction capabilities, offering constructability reviews, helping owners evaluate materials and systems, or identifying value engineering opportunities before designs are finalized.

For some contractors, it could mean incorporating 4D modeling to demonstrate construction sequencing, using virtual reality to help clients visualize projects, or introducing prefabrication strategies that reduce schedule disruptions.

Technology isn’t inherently valuable because it’s impressive. It becomes valuable when it helps owners make better decisions, reduce risk, improve outcomes, or solve challenges they haven’t fully considered.

The same principle applies to your subcontractors. Selecting the cheapest subcontractor might lower your proposed construction cost, but an unreliable or inexperienced trade partner can create schedule delays, quality problems, and expensive rework. A more capable subcontractor may also identify constructability improvements and cost-saving alternatives that the cheapest bidder never considered.

If the only value you can explain is your cost to build plus a markup, you haven’t given a client much reason to negotiate with you.

Start Treating Every Client Like a Preferred Client

One of the best heavy civil contractors I’ve worked with demonstrated this philosophy through its company culture.

They performed substantial competitively bid public work, but leadership insisted those projects receive the same customer experience as their private work.

Their teams communicated proactively, maintained friendly and collaborative relationships, and approached challenges as though they were on the client’s team rather than on the opposite side of the negotiating table.

Instead of waiting for instructions and treating every problem as a potential dispute, they looked for opportunities to help clients solve problems and improve outcomes.

The company established one standard for how employees treated clients, regardless of the procurement method.

That approach also contributed to improved employee retention. Employees weren’t expected to operate with two different attitudes depending on whether the job came from competitive bidding or a longstanding client relationship. They could take pride in consistently delivering a better experience.

This illustrates something important about the transition toward negotiated work.

You don’t have to wait until you win a negotiated project to start behaving like a preferred contractor.

Better Relationships Begin With Understanding the Client

When contractors decide they want more negotiated work, I recommend starting with clients who already know and trust them.

These relationships give contractors an opportunity to have conversations that would be more difficult with unfamiliar prospects.

Ask about the client’s upcoming projects, their challenges with past construction experiences, and where they believe contractors could provide more value. Learn what causes their projects to exceed budgets, miss schedules, or create unnecessary headaches.

Sometimes the most valuable market research is simply talking with your clients and genuinely listening to their answers.

You may discover opportunities to provide earlier budgeting assistance, participate in design decisions, improve communication with stakeholders, or address recurring project challenges.

Then explore whether the client has opportunities for negotiated, best-value, design-build, or other collaborative procurement approaches.

Public agencies deserve special consideration. Some have expanded their use of alternative delivery methods, while others operate under procurement laws that require competitive low-bid selection for particular projects. Contractors must understand the applicable rules rather than assuming a relationship can change how a public contract is awarded.

Even when a client must use low-bid procurement, understanding its challenges can help you become a better partner and improve your ability to compete on future opportunities.

A Simple Three-Question Go/No-Go Test

One exercise I’ve used with contractors is a simple Go/No-Go assessment built around three questions:

  1. Do we have relevant project experience? Have we successfully completed similar work, and can we demonstrate that experience in a way that’s meaningful to this client?
  2. Does the client know our capabilities? Do the decision-makers understand our expertise, resources, strengths, and how we differ from other contractors?
  3. Do we understand the client’s real challenges and pain points? Do we know what matters beyond the plans, specifications, and construction budget?

These questions don’t replace a comprehensive Go/No-Go evaluation that considers profitability, capacity, risk, and other factors. They help reveal whether the contractor has the experience, relationships, and client understanding needed to compete on value.

If you have relevant experience but the client doesn’t know your capabilities, you have a positioning and relationship-building challenge.

If the client knows you but you don’t understand its real problems, you have more discovery to do.

And if you don’t have relevant experience, you need to determine whether the opportunity fits your growth strategy or whether you’re simply chasing revenue.

Notice that none of these questions asks whether you’re willing to offer the lowest price.

Evolve One Project at a Time

Transitioning toward negotiated work doesn’t mean abandoning competitive bidding, and it certainly doesn’t happen overnight.

Contractors have employees to support, equipment to utilize, and backlog to maintain. Making a sudden change to their pursuit strategy could create unnecessary financial risk.

Start with one existing client relationship. Find one upcoming project where you can demonstrate more value. Explore one additional service that solves a meaningful client problem. Improve one part of the client experience that distinguishes your company.

Then build on what you learn.

Negotiated work can create opportunities for stronger margins because contractors have more room to demonstrate differentiation, collaborate earlier, and compete on value rather than price alone. But negotiation doesn’t guarantee profitability. Owners still have budgets, financing constraints, and projects that may be delayed or canceled if the economics don’t work.

The objective isn’t to eliminate competitive bids or maximize the percentage of negotiated contracts. It’s to build a healthier mix of more profitable, predictable, better-fit work.

Your company shouldn’t be defined by how cheaply it can build a project. It should be known for the value it creates for the clients it serves.

That transition starts with how leadership thinks about growth, continues through how the company operates, and becomes visible in the relationships and opportunities it earns.


Next in the Series: Stop Bidding Everything: Find the Construction Work Worth Winning

More bids don’t necessarily mean more wins or better profits. In Part 3, we’ll examine the hidden costs of chasing every opportunity, how better Go/No-Go decisions can improve your hit rate, and why sometimes the smartest business decision is to let a competitor win the project.

How Marketing Helps Contractors Win More Negotiated Work

When a contractor tells me they want more negotiated work, there is usually another problem hiding underneath that goal. Margins are getting squeezed. They’re losing projects they believe they should win. They’re tired of competing against a dozen contractors on price, spending time estimating jobs they will never get, and running faster for less profit.

They want off the hamster wheel, and the instinct is often to put the responsibility on business development. Build more relationships. Make more calls. Attend more events. Get in front of more owners.

Those things matter, but negotiated work is rarely created by business development alone. It starts with building preference before the project exists, which is where marketing becomes much more important than lead generation and proposals.

Winning Negotiated Work Starts With a Mindset Shift

Contractors that consistently earn negotiated opportunities tend to think differently about the market. They become pickier about the clients and projects they pursue, make clearer choices about where they are particularly valuable, and demonstrate expertise rather than acting like order takers.

They are also willing to tell buyers how they would solve a problem instead of simply waiting for plans and specifications. Marketing helps translate that mindset into the market.

I’ve seen contractors use stronger positioning, improved brand identities, clearer messaging, thought leadership, differentiation, and account-based marketing to make themselves more relevant to the clients they actually want. None of those tactics magically creates negotiated work on its own, but together they change what a buyer knows and believes about the contractor before the buying decision begins.

Marketing Should Start Before Anyone Knows About the Project

The highest-leverage time to market to a future client is often before anyone knows there is a project. By the time an opportunity is publicly bid, much of the advantage is already gone.

A future client may have been reading your insights for a year. They might follow one of your executives on LinkedIn, recognize your trucks around town, have seen projects you’ve completed, heard your name from peers, and regularly received useful information from your company. Then a project begins taking shape, and your firm is already familiar.

That’s the opportunity marketing should help create. Its job is not simply to generate a form submission at the moment someone needs a contractor. Marketing should help attract the right clients, nurture them over time, and position your people as subject-matter experts long before the project reaches procurement.

People Buy From People. Marketing Helps Them Choose Which People.

Construction is still a relationship business, and I don’t expect that to change. But “people buy from people” is sometimes used as an excuse for contractors to underinvest in marketing because it assumes the relationship begins when the salesperson shakes someone’s hand.

It doesn’t. Prospective clients research contractors constantly, and I’ve seen that throughout my career in construction marketing. They look at your website, search your executives, review projects, look at social media, ask peers about you, and evaluate whether your company appears to understand their type of work.

Marketing determines much of what they find. It doesn’t replace the human relationship, but it can attract the right clients, nurture those clients, establish your people as subject-matter experts, and give the relationship somewhere stronger to start.

Reputation Does Not Automatically Travel

This becomes painfully obvious when a successful contractor enters a new geography or market sector. You may have a phenomenal reputation in your hometown. Your phone rings because owners have known your company for 30 years, your superintendent has built five projects for the same client, and your CEO knows half the market personally.

Drive three hours away, and none of that necessarily matters. Without a strong portfolio, recognizable brand, clear differentiation, and visible expertise, you can be dead on arrival in a new market.

That’s why expansion requires more than opening an office and hiring a business developer. Marketing has to transfer the company’s credibility into a form that strangers can understand. From the start, buyers need to see what you’re good at, where you’ve done it, what problems you’ve solved, and why you’re worth considering.

Your Project Pages Are Probably Showing the Wrong Things

Most construction project profiles focus heavily on finished-project statistics: square footage, contract value, location, architect, completion date, and then a collection of beautiful professional photographs.

Those things provide useful proof, but they’re usually not what makes the story persuasive. A stronger project profile answers a different question: What made the project difficult, and what did your team do about it?

Maybe the client had to keep an occupied facility operational throughout construction. Perhaps the schedule was compressed, material availability threatened the critical path, the site was constrained, safety risks were unusually high, or existing conditions were different than expected. Those are the details that reveal how your team actually creates value.

Progress photos can sometimes be more persuasive than polished final photography because they reveal phasing, coordination, logistics, temporary protection, sequencing, prefabrication, problem-solving, and the messy reality behind the finished project.

The completed building proves you built it. The story of how you built it demonstrates why someone should trust you with the next one.

Thought Leadership Should Demonstrate How You Solve Problems

Construction thought leadership does not have to mean publishing grand predictions about the future of the industry. Some of the best content simply answers practical questions clients are already wrestling with and demonstrates how your people think.

How can an owner protect the schedule when procurement lead times are increasing? How should construction be phased inside an occupied facility? What design decisions create unnecessary costs? What safety risks should an industrial owner consider before work begins? How can preconstruction improve budget certainty?

These topics demonstrate expertise in the things buyers care about most, including budget, schedule, safety, risk, and communication. Occupied construction is a particularly strong example because a contractor can demonstrate expertise around logistics, employee or customer safety, noise, dust, access, phasing, shutdown planning, and communication.

That is much more compelling than publishing another article saying your company is committed to “quality, safety, and integrity.” Show the buyer how you think instead.

Business Development and Marketing Need the Same Target

Marketing cannot build preference effectively if marketing and business development are pursuing different companies. At minimum, the two functions should share the same ideal client profile, target account list, understanding of the brand personality and positioning, CRM, and approach to attribution.

If business development has 50 dream accounts, marketing should know who they are. Those accounts should influence the content you produce, projects you feature, events you attend, campaigns you run, leaders you promote, and expertise you develop publicly.

This is where account-based marketing can be particularly useful for contractors. Rather than asking marketing to produce a large number of anonymous “leads,” marketing and business development work together to increase familiarity, relevance, and engagement inside a defined group of companies the contractor actually wants to work with.

Do Not Forget the Clients You Already Have

The other high-leverage opportunity is client retention. Contractors can spend enormous amounts of energy winning a client and remarkably little staying relevant after the project ends, which is a mistake if the goal is more negotiated work.

Past clients already know whether you can perform, so the trust hurdle is much lower. Marketing can keep the relationship warm between projects through useful content, project updates, executive communication, newsletters, client events, and expertise that continues helping clients make better decisions.

That matters when the next project arrives 18 months later. Being remembered is part of being invited, and client retention should be treated as part of the negotiated-work strategy rather than something marketing stops thinking about after the ribbon cutting.

How Do You Measure Whether This Is Working?

Marketing’s contribution to negotiated work will never fit neatly into a last-click attribution report. A $50 million opportunity may begin with a relationship developed over several years and involve a referral, six executive conversations, a dozen pieces of content, three completed projects, a conference, and repeated visits to your website.

Assigning all of that revenue to the last website visit would be ridiculous. Instead, I would watch a combination of business and marketing indicators, including inbound inquiries from the types of clients you actually want, the percentage of work that is negotiated versus hard bid, engagement from target accounts, repeat and referral opportunities, and whether business development is becoming easier.

That last measure is underrated. Ask the people responsible for growth whether prospects are more familiar with the company when they walk into the room, whether clients understand the firm’s value faster, whether the right companies are reaching out, and whether the team is getting invited into conversations earlier.

Those are meaningful signs that preference is growing.

The Goal Isn’t More Leads. It’s More Preference.

Construction marketing often gets reduced to websites, social media, proposals, and lead generation, but those are outputs. The larger job is to help the market understand why your company is worth choosing.

That means attracting the right clients, nurturing them before they have an immediate need, making your expertise visible, equipping business development with a stronger story, and giving current clients reasons to continue seeing value in the relationship.

If you’re tired of competing for low-margin work after the project has already hit the street, don’t simply ask how marketing can generate more leads. Ask how you can become the contractor the client already wants before the project ever goes out to bid.

That is where negotiated work begins.


Next in the Series: Why Your Construction Company Is Stuck Competing on Low Bid

Most contractors start by competing on price, but that approach can eventually limit their growth. In Part 2, we’ll explore why contractors become dependent on low-bid work, the mindset that keeps them there, and what it takes to evolve into a preferred contractor.